I like the CS2 version better. If guild logo's can be custom made in huxley - it would be a great one because it looks gritty. I believe the squinting eyes are better because it helps keep the face behind it mysterious. Red is a good color for evil but having blue eyes with a white center work as well.
Red things for eyes are all too common you know?
Try making the horns on fire.... not made of fire but ON fire.
Also the metal could use a little shine - and I mean a little because we still want it to be kinda - "battle worn".
But that's just my opinion
